Moved by

Lord Weir of Ballyholme

30: Clause 1, page 1, line 12, at end insert—

“(e) is not substantially motivated by—

(i) not wanting to be a burden on others or on public services,

(ii) a mental disorder (including depression),

(iii) a disability (other than the terminal illness),

(iv) financial considerations, including a lack of adequate...

Moved by

Lord Weir of Ballyholme

30: Clause 1, page 1, line 12, at end insert—

“(e) is not substantially motivated by—

(i) not wanting to be a burden on others or on public services,

(ii) a mental disorder (including depression),

(iii) a disability (other than the terminal illness),

(iv) financial considerations, including a lack of adequate...

My Lords, I have notified the Lord Speaker’s office and the Whips that I shall be moving Amendment 30, which stands in my name and those of the noble Baronesses, Lady Foster—who is unable to be with us today—and Lady Fox, and the noble Lord, Lord Empey. This group of...

My Lords, I have notified the Lord Speaker’s office and the Whips that I shall be moving Amendment 30, which stands in my name and those of the noble Baronesses, Lady Foster—who is unable to be with us today—and Lady Fox, and the noble Lord, Lord Empey. This group of...

Moved by

Baroness Lawlor

30ZA: Before sub-paragraph (i), insert—

“(ai) not wanting to cause distress or be a burden on their families,”

Moved by

Baroness Lawlor

30ZA: Before sub-paragraph (i), insert—

“(ai) not wanting to cause distress or be a burden on their families,”

My Lords, I support all six sub-paragraphs in the amendment in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Foster of Aghadrumsee, which was moved by the noble Lord, Lord Weir of Ballyholme, and is supported by the noble Baroness, Lady Fox, and the noble Lord, Lord Empey. However, I urge...

My Lords, I support all six sub-paragraphs in the amendment in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Foster of Aghadrumsee, which was moved by the noble Lord, Lord Weir of Ballyholme, and is supported by the noble Baroness, Lady Fox, and the noble Lord, Lord Empey. However, I urge...

Just so that I can properly respond to this, which amendment in the group is this addressed to?

Just so that I can properly respond to this, which amendment in the group is this addressed to?

It is addressed to Amendment 30ZA amending Amendment 30. It is on page 2 of Today’s Lists.

It is all too easy imagine such appeals by a family to altruistic feelings. They do not want to cause distress or be a burden, especially to those they most love. In the dismal...

It is addressed to Amendment 30ZA amending Amendment 30. It is on page 2 of Today’s Lists.

It is all too easy imagine such appeals by a family to altruistic feelings. They do not want to cause distress or be a burden, especially to those they most love. In the dismal...

My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 30 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Foster of Aghadrumsee, and the noble Lord, Lord Weir of Ballyholme. I also support the other amendments in this group.

I first put on record that while I like and respect the Government Chief Whip,...

My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 30 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Foster of Aghadrumsee, and the noble Lord, Lord Weir of Ballyholme. I also support the other amendments in this group.

I first put on record that while I like and respect the Government Chief Whip,...

My Lords, all these amendments address motivation, one of the areas that the noble and learned Lord, Lord Falconer, identified as a key area in his email sent to some noble Lords on Wednesday. This therefore feels an appropriate moment to make some short observations on general matters arising from...

My Lords, all these amendments address motivation, one of the areas that the noble and learned Lord, Lord Falconer, identified as a key area in his email sent to some noble Lords on Wednesday. This therefore feels an appropriate moment to make some short observations on general matters arising from...

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Monckton of Dallington Forest, for that excellently clear way of expressing some of the discomfort and what we would like to see. I would be much happier and feel that I did not have to speak too much if I was getting...

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Monckton of Dallington Forest, for that excellently clear way of expressing some of the discomfort and what we would like to see. I would be much happier and feel that I did not have to speak too much if I was getting...

My Lords, I am associated with some of these amendments. I do not think we want to get completely hung up on the minutiae of each particular line, because there are variations that one could make. I guess that when one is drafting a Bill there are choices to be...

My Lords, I am associated with some of these amendments. I do not think we want to get completely hung up on the minutiae of each particular line, because there are variations that one could make. I guess that when one is drafting a Bill there are choices to be...

My Lords, in connection with Amendment 30, I will just say, in a point of distinction to some of the speeches, that if I were interested in having an assisted death, part of the reason would most definitely be that I would not want to be a burden on my...

My Lords, in connection with Amendment 30, I will just say, in a point of distinction to some of the speeches, that if I were interested in having an assisted death, part of the reason would most definitely be that I would not want to be a burden on my...

My Lords, I will touch on Amendments 30, 56 and 57, the latter two to which I have attached my name. Before I launch into my arguments, it is, if I may say so, a delight for me to see the noble Baroness, Lady Campbell of Surbiton, in her place...

My Lords, I will touch on Amendments 30, 56 and 57, the latter two to which I have attached my name. Before I launch into my arguments, it is, if I may say so, a delight for me to see the noble Baroness, Lady Campbell of Surbiton, in her place...

My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Harper; when he was a Minister, we had many interesting discussions, although they were possibly not as collaborative as those with my noble friend Lady Campbell. This group talks about motivation and I am sure we are...

My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Harper; when he was a Minister, we had many interesting discussions, although they were possibly not as collaborative as those with my noble friend Lady Campbell. This group talks about motivation and I am sure we are...

My Lords, I hope the noble and learned Lord, Lord Falconer, will forgive me for intervening at this stage. I know we are all in a hurry, and I have not got my name on any of the amendments—yet. Noble Lords will know that I have been away for over...

My Lords, I hope the noble and learned Lord, Lord Falconer, will forgive me for intervening at this stage. I know we are all in a hurry, and I have not got my name on any of the amendments—yet. Noble Lords will know that I have been away for over...

My Lords, I too warmly welcome the return of my noble friend Lady Campbell—the most extraordinary person and advocate for disabled people and so many more in our societies. I just remind the Committee that, in all these discussions about burdens and people who have had a stroke— I am...

My Lords, I too warmly welcome the return of my noble friend Lady Campbell—the most extraordinary person and advocate for disabled people and so many more in our societies. I just remind the Committee that, in all these discussions about burdens and people who have had a stroke— I am...

I may just build on that, because the noble Baroness is quite right that it is six months. This is absolutely about choice, and behind that choice is the person’s motivation. Of course pain is a very valid reason, but it is not the only reason as, again, research has...

I may just build on that, because the noble Baroness is quite right that it is six months. This is absolutely about choice, and behind that choice is the person’s motivation. Of course pain is a very valid reason, but it is not the only reason as, again, research has...

My Lords, this is an important and moving debate. It is an honour to speak in it and to follow some of the previous contributions. These amendments highlight the fact that eligibility is not the same as motivation. I agree

with almost everything that has been said before me; I...

My Lords, this is an important and moving debate. It is an honour to speak in it and to follow some of the previous contributions. These amendments highlight the fact that eligibility is not the same as motivation. I agree

with almost everything that has been said before me; I...

My Lords, I will briefly speak to these amendments, in particular to Amendment 30. I know from listening to previous groups that the Minister will feel the need to explain that Amendment 30, as drafted, is not fit for purpose and will not help the Bill. However, in Committee, the...

My Lords, I will briefly speak to these amendments, in particular to Amendment 30. I know from listening to previous groups that the Minister will feel the need to explain that Amendment 30, as drafted, is not fit for purpose and will not help the Bill. However, in Committee, the...

My Lords, it is a privilege to follow the noble Baronesses, Lady Grey-Thompson and Lady Campbell, who articulated for us the suddenness with which those with a disability can move into the category of those for whom death is imminent. It can happen very suddenly, without warning. Their contributions were...

My Lords, it is a privilege to follow the noble Baronesses, Lady Grey-Thompson and Lady Campbell, who articulated for us the suddenness with which those with a disability can move into the category of those for whom death is imminent. It can happen very suddenly, without warning. Their contributions were...

My Lords, I agree with everyone who has said that we must ask the question: what is the motivation for that individual? I submit that, unless a doctor can ask that question, they are not able to discharge their duties in two ways. First, they cannot assess the capacity of...

My Lords, I agree with everyone who has said that we must ask the question: what is the motivation for that individual? I submit that, unless a doctor can ask that question, they are not able to discharge their duties in two ways. First, they cannot assess the capacity of...